My view is they will have to pay Bay closer to Drew money than Youkilis money. It hasn't helped them with Bay that they were willing to pay Texeira how much? before the season. Bay has turned out to be the power hitter he was in Pittsburgh and more in Boston, though he has slumped a bit lately. Clearly, they need him in the middle of their lineup. Right now, Youks looks like his equal, but he wasn't the established power hitter he is now when they extended him at $10 mil per--what is now a bargain. As for Drew, he received the Boras bonus--every Boras client costs more.
I think they'll have to be in the 5/70 range to get Bay. Why? Because he can easily get that on the open market. Nickle and diming one of your top hitters doesn't make much sense to me. Theo has wasted more than that signing FA busts at SS in recent years.