If you use Victorino's career .770 OPS (he played injured for large portions of '10), the difference between him and Stubbs (who can't get on base to save his life) becomes much more apparent. Stubbs is not better than Victorino. That is a stretch.
Also, i think the Phillies' weakness against LHP is a bit overblown, since the only guy in the Phillies lineup that is absolutely weak against left-handers is Howard.
I never said they weren't similar, i just think that, completely healthy, the Phillies have a better lineup than the Reds, and why wouldn't the Phillies get another OF? It doesn't have to be a guy who makes a ton of money, they simply need a guy that can hit LHP to platoon with Brown who, by the way, might be better than Stubbs if given the chance next year.