A lot of people seem to have trouble with telling the difference between a good idea that didn't work, a meh idea that didn't work, and a bad idea. For many here, everything that didn't work was a terrible decision. I personally feel like the decision to, say, leave Josh Beckett in the game in the 5th inning is something you ought to be able to expect to do, even if he was struggling with an injury at the time. The fact that that decision didn't work out does not automatically mean the decision was a mistake. It may, but it's not a 1-1 correlation like some people seem to be suggesting.