That goes back to sort of what I was ineptly trying to say. Strategy vs. tactics.
the "tactical" situation, IE any one game, yeah sure, play Drew. But you know he's going to need regular rest. If he doesn't get it he might not be in any condition to help us in October. Bearing that in mind, why not use Baldelli against lefthanders not necessarily beacuse Drew is bad against lefties, but because Baldelli is good against them and that ensures the built-in rest Drew needs while giving him an excuse not to play without being seen as a total wuss?
Seen that way, the tactic might not have put us in the best position to win every possible game, but the strategy is paying off. we're most of the way through the season and Drew is still effective and healthy -- at least as healthy as he ever is.