I love Jacoby, but we'd still have Coco, who is stellar in CF, if not at the plate. He could come around there, though. Santana is only 28. We'd have Beckett, Santana, Matsuzaka and Bucholz set in stone for the next 6 years, more or less. Ellsbury was very impressive during his short spell with the big club. There is no prolonged peroid of sustained major league stats that he's put up, whereas Santana is a proven stud, maybe the best pitcher in the game. You gotta do the deal. Pitching: Santana. Defense: Coco. Pitching and Defense equal..........