in 2003, theo refused to trade casey fossum for bartolo colon. why? bartolo was old and washed up, and fossum was the future. you think he suddnely changed his mind when a 38 year old who was on the DL named curt became available? No. Lucchino told him to make that move. Theo has shown one thing: He will not trade young pitching prospects for veterans. that is his golden rule (hansen for oswalt?).
And Foulke was Theo's move? What? Theo hates paying money for closers. His first act of genius was "closer by committee". But the next year he went out and bought the most expensive closer on the market? Again, no f'ing way!! Lucchino.
And I don't think it was Theo refusing to trade Manny. Theo wanted Manny GONE. That, again, was Lucchino insisting.
Theo did trade Nomar, I'll give him credit for that. But those other moves were Larry. It wasn't until post 2004 when Theo finally received control of the team, and he's been blunder after blunder since.