There are many moves I would have made. First would have been to keep Ocab. There was no reason to let him go. Assuming I took control of the team after they let him go and we had acquired Renteria, I would have kept him on the team even after his off-year. It was a knee-jerk reaction trading him after one bad season.
Lets see. In July of the '06 season I would have traded some youth (not the main guys) for pitching depth and another bat. That would have possibly prevented our collapse. I was soo pissed when Theo did NOTHING while the Yankees got Abreu and destroyed us.
I wouldn't have signed either Lugo or Drew. I wouldn't need a SS since I would have kept Ocab, or Renteria if I came after that. For RF I would have either stuck with Trot for 1 more year and waited (the CF FA market for this off-season is deep) or signed an available FA for a 1-2 year deal (team option).
I would have gone after Dice-K. I agree with that move.
I would have signed Jima.
I would have gone after Gagne, I liked that move.
I would release Gagne after this season.
I would not resign Schilling.
I would look to add another Starter (FA or trade (FA SP is shallow). You always need a lot of depth at SP.
I would look to add another arm to the pen. I'd look strongly at MDC moving into the setup role if he is ready, if not Jima is fine another year.
I would go get a CF (I would still go after Andrew Jones even after his off year. I would probably focus on Torii Hunter tough).
I would then probably have the FA acquisition start in CF and move Ellsbury to RF. (unless the FA agreed to move to LF, but thats more of a manager's decision).
I would pursue Arod if he opts out. If he doesn't, or he doesn't want to play for Boston, I resign Lowell.
Thats off the top of my head right now, I'll go a bit more indepth after a bit of research tomorrow afternoon. I'm going to bed.
On a side note: I don't think Theo is the worst GM ever, but he has made his share of mistakes, some big ones I believe (Drew), but the fact is that he is the GM for the Red Sox and he is held to the highest of standards.
Oh and I left out some more:
Damon is a tough decision. It is really based on scouting. If scouting truely believes he will suck after 2 years of the deal, than I think you have to let him go. If your not confident in that, I would probably have to resign him, if anything, to keep him away from NY. I'll be honest though and say that I can't make a perfectly educated decision as I don't have all the resources/facts right now. But I certainly don't criticize Theo for letting him go.
Millar, thats an obvious one. Let him go.
Bill Mueller, I loved the guy, but it was his time to go.
The Beckett trade was a good trade. I hated letting Hanley go, but it was obviously a good trade for us. I would have made that trade.
Ok thats enough for now, really. I'll go more indepth tomorrow.