Pumps, Cherington is responsible for 2 trades, the Ross signing, the Scutaro deal, the Papi negotations, the retooled pen and the Bard experiment. Otherwise, petitioning the owners for more money isnt going to work since they have made it clear they need to get under the $189 million tax threshold for next season. He could offer to fellatiate John Henry at his beck and call and it still wouldnt work. You cannot kill him for not raising the payroll
You can kill Cherington on the trades for now. Reddick is turning into an all star level OFer for a team badly in need of offense. The sox got back a no power RFer and a closer who hasnt suited up once for the sox
Lowrie has been one of the most productive shortstops in baseball in Houston while Mark Melancon has been an enigma/juggs machine in Boston.
The Ross signing was pure genius and might make all of the above go away if he can be dealt for something of long term value
The Papi negotiations were far from great, but he got him on a one yr deal, which also could end up being a humongous boon for the org if they deal him for someone with long term value
The Scutaro deal at the time was a money saving move that allowed you to get Ross. Mortensen looks like he could be a valuable piece for this team going forward, so the deal doesnt actually look that bad in retrospect even with the issues the sox have had in the IF
The rebuilt pen is all on Cherington. His hands were all over the Miller transformation, the Padilla signing, the Cook signing, the Aceves move to the closers role, etc. Cherington did in one yr what Theo never did and that is build a good bullpen. It might be smoke and mirrors, but the results to this point are great.
You can definitely kill Cherington for the Bard experiment. I think Bobby made it pretty clear that he wanted Bard in the pen but was overruled. Now the kid cannot get minor leaguers out and has lost his stuff. If Bard never regains his form, then that singular decision could be the deathknell for him in Boston. Taking your relief ace, a guy who was shut down dominant for 2 seasons and turning him into a shell shocked soldier hiding from combat is all on him.