Here is how I view Girardi.
Girardi is still feeling his way through this team. There is a ton of turnover as well as a TON of injuries. Not many teams can handle losing their ace and then the guy who steps in as their ace. Essentially your top 2 starters. Then to have your #4 and #5 starters go down with injury and ineffectiveness. I said at the start of the yr that the yankees starters went 6 deep including Chamberlain. Well, 4 have missed significant time.
Not to mention the turnover in the lineup. Jorge Posada was considered to be one of the most irreplaceable yankees since he broke into the bigs around 1998. He wasnt himself from day 1 and is now out for the yr. It is tough losing a player who hit .338 with 20HR and a .900+OPS and turning that into a guy who can barely OPS .600. While defense is certainly a factor, Posada's loss on the offensive side of the ball is unquestioned.
Then you lose 3 weeks of ARod and Damon. Hideki Matsui, who was hitting .320 and last yr had a .800+OPS and 100+RBI season has missed 50 games and counting. Then factor in Cano and Melky going into the tank for the full yr for the most part and all things considered, Girardi has faced more adversity than can be imagined.
In terms of what he has done, you really need to take a look at the culture that was left behind. Joe Torre was a guy who came into Yankee lore in the mid 90s as a National League manager in the AL. He bunted, hit and ran, bunted for hits, etc. That stopped being employed by him for some reason and we have seen too many ploddingly slow players bounce into DPs because of it. That being said, Girardi is an NL style manager and he was an NL style player. Bunting and hit and run are part of his game. Getting back to today's game, I agree wholeheartedly with bunting Jeter in that spot. He hits into DPs all day long, Lackey gets GIDPs like it is his job and Abreu is a dynamite hitter with RISP. It was the right call.
In terms of his bullpen management, Girardi and Torre are on absolute opposite ends of the spectrum. Torre was a guy who pulled pitchers at 100 pitches or any time there was a hint of trouble from innings 6 on. Girardi is the kid of guy who lets pitchers get out of their own jams, even if they are obviously done. Torre wouldnt use the kids to save his life, using only 2 or 3 middle relievers ad nauseum and letting the other guys rot. Essentially making those 2 or 3 burn out by mid yr and the other guys rusty come time for them to be called upon. Girardi is not like that. He seems to use guys who are a bit green in key spots to get them battle tested. I am unsure if this is a way for him to toughen the kids up or a way for him to learn what these kids have. I would hope that he slots these guys into formed roles come next yr. Today was bad. Geise was dominating. Veras comes in and gets hit hard, but it wasnt all that obvious that he would do so. Edwar, OTOH, is a guy who is absolutely reliant on an off speed pitch and not necessarily best equipped for a must win game.
Regardless, come next yr, I think Girardi will have made more progress than regress. I still think Veras is a closer in the making and we have turned Edwar from a waste heap guy to a middle reliever capable of eating innings. He also threw Robertson into the fire and it is obvious that he has the goods to get the job done. Throw in Melancon coming down the pipe and Marte now in the fold and our pen will have experience and solid power to start the yr.
In terms of how Girardi is doing in terms of today, he gets a C from me, mostly for his choice of Edwar in a tied game against HR hitters. But I agreed with the bunt and am glad he let Geise get through 6.
Regardless, it might be time for Joe to think about next yr and getting the kids into the games as much as possible. This team has taken on way too much water. If you want to point at something that our playoff teams with late season surges had in common was health. By the end of the yr, most of our guys came back. Hence, we made a hell of a run when guys came back fresh. This yr has been backwards. We started the yr healthy and are seeing guys drop off like flies as the season comes to a close.