Ok, to simplify this, i'll turn Power hitters into Cookies.
Whats better, 3 cookies, or 4 cookies?
Also, referring the WMP being figured out by opposing pitchers, his BA dropped maybe 20 points in from ths AS break. From a .325ish to .301 by the end of the season. You can't say it's because he was figured out, it could of been lack of consistant at bats or just genuine fatigue.