Catchers:
Varitek - Villain - Regressed in nearly every facet of his game this season, came up incredibly small in the playoffs.
Cash - Joe - Exceeded offensive expectations (not hard to do when you have one of the worst OPS+ in MLB history, I believe his was 27 coming into this season - handled Wake well, don't want him on the team next season)
Ross - Ghost - Thought he'd be used more, disappointing he wasn't with Varitek's struggles.
1B:
Youkilis - Hero - MVP
Kotsay - Joe - His approach was infuriating at times, but he performed admirably in the playoffs at 1B - there was a three week stretch towards the end of September when he didn't hit anything but hit quite well in the playoffs.
Casey - Joe - Great 1st half, disappointing 2nd half, no flexibility in how to use the roster spot, bet he's gone.
Bailey - Joe - IL MVP, did all you can ask from a career minor leaguer, should have made the ALCS roster over Timlin.
2B:
Pedroia - Hero - MVP
SS:
Lugo - Joe/Villain - Sunk cost. Hope he's gone.
Lowrie - Joe - Started off gangbusters - overpowered by good fastballs, worrisome split from left side.
Cora - Villain - Getting hit by a pitch is not a skill, empty BA, terrible defense.
3B:
Lowell - Joe/Villain - Disappointing year. Couldn't stay healthy. Playing hurt was counterproductive to the Sox's success.
OF:
Manny - Villain - Sucked for the entire month of June. Disappointing end to a good run in Boston. Wonder what could have been if he kept his mouth shut.
Bay - Hero - Came in an performed in a tight spot exceedingly well. Look for a big year next year.
Crisp - Joe/Hero - Average start to his season, best offensive CF in baseball since August and handled being benched like a consummate professional.
Ellsbury - Joe/Villain -Shares the blame with Tito for his atrocious season in the leadoff spot. Had a good April, OK may, OK September, terrible summer. 50 steals is a nice number, awfully empty BA, good to great defense.
Drew - Hero - Team MVP in June, team leader in OPS for much of the season, clutch god in the postseason.
Moss - Joe - Great start to the season, appendicitis set him back IMO. Lost in the deal for Bay - probably the player that (a) sucked to lose the most [most talent] but ( was the most expendable [with Bailey, Carter, Van Every, etc]
DH:
Ortiz - Joe/Villain - Played hurt much of the year, but like Lowell, really hurt the team with lack of production. Terrible start to the season when healthy, too. Looking for a big year next year with the wrist healed.