I'd rather see JD Drew in that role.. granted he doesn't have the SB's obviously he gets on base a lot more.. I don't think SB's alone make a leadoff guy.. Ellsbury seems to hit spots where he just doesn't make it to first as often as a leafoff guy should and he never seems to want that free pass.. Drew has a lot more discipline at the plate and his OBP is nearly .050 higher which could translate to more runs in the long run..
Ellsbury should be batting 7th, 8th or 9th until he finally learns to take a pitch
this applies as long as Drew can stay healthy, of course..