Alright alright...
So I freaked out when I first heard this move when it was delivered by my future wife Erin Andrews during the Sox/Phils game today. After giving it some serious serious thought...I've decided that, assuming it's not a panic move health-wise, I really like the idea. I feel far more confident about 9th innings now...actually, I shouldn't even say more confident, because that indicates that I had SOME confidence previously, which I most certainly did not.
Am I scared to death as to what kind of bed-s***ing JT is going to do every fifth day? Yea, kind of. But at the same rate, I'm really excited about what this offense can do, and don't think the Sox will have to worry about winning many 2-1 or 1-0 games. These guys will put runs on the board, making it unneccessary for JT to be nasty on an everyday basis...or s***...even an any day basis. If he's halfway competent, he'll win his fair share of games. And he's only a stopgap, IMO, until Lester is ready or Clemens comes around, probably the former.
I also find myself questioning sometimes how effective a starter Paps would have been. I was excited about seeing what he could put together...but I had my reservations. Closers can get by on 2 pitches...starters can't. Before you all freak out on me, realize that I know Paps has a curveball and a change also, but when you think of what he threw last year, those aren't what you think about. You think about the heat and the split...his two elite pitches. I'm more comfortable having him stick to those and mow guys down in the ninth than have him throw average hooks during 7 innings of work. They're effective occasionally out of the pen because guys don't see them a lot. If you're facing Paps 3 and 4 times in a game, you're going to get more comfortable on them and hit them a quarter mile.
I love Papelbon...I really really do. I'm giving the FO the benefit of the doubt and say they looked into the best interest of his shoulder and were given the all-clear by the doctors. That said, the only reservations I have is that we've never seen Papelbon close in the post-season. I really hope he can cut the mustard on the biggest stage in the game. And I'll tell you what, I can't wait to see him try. And I really think this team can give us all the opportunity to see that.