Millar sucked, horribly, for 2 years. He can be compared well to Jason Giambi before his resurgence last year, and the Yankees tried to void his contract.
I don't know ANYBODY criticizing Bill Mueller. Just about every red sox fan would love to have had him back. The decision to let him leave was because he wanted a 3 year contract. For someone like him, that is a risk. Thats not blasting the guys, its a fact. People are saying Lowell could come here and put up good HR numbers becasue very recently he has, while playing in Florida. No one is saying this is a sure thing, far from it. He is definately our biggest question mark, but was the price of acquiring Josh Beckett.
Derek Lowe, I will always appreciate how well he pitched in the post season. When starters go on 3 days rest in the playoffs the station covering the game generally runs a stat about how past pitchers have struggled in this situation. Lowe beat the yankees in game 7 on 2!!! days rest. He was just terribly inconsistent and got a ton of money. Again, not blasting the guy, its just a fact hes not worth that contract.
Pedro. If you want to see what Red Sox fans think of him then watch the game if he pitches against us for the Mets this year. I think he deserves a standing ovation longer than Ripken got when he broke the consecutive games played record. He has lost 8 mph on his fastball and his HR numbers have gone up. He has gone from the best pitcher in the history of the game to above average, and there is good reason to believe he will continue to get worse with his shoulder. Thats an honest opinion. Giving him a big 4 year contract would've been risky. I would've supported it and hoped everything turned out well if the Red Sox gave it to him, but it would've made me nervous.
Your opinion is mainly responding to what the press has said. The Boston Media sucks and does not speak for the general fan base. ESPECIALLY not Shaughnessy.