ok, i'll try to refute some of these, the ones I don't I agree with you on.
1. I pretty much agree with you on this one, however the only thing I will say is look at 2004, when Millar started slow but then picked it up big time in the second half. I think that was justifyable for awhile but he should have not gotten any playing time after August. Samething with Belhorn, I mean come'on these guys were huge contributers for the first championship run, he wasn't just going to abbandon them after a slow first month. I think with Belhorn he was pretty much burried by mid-june anyways.
2. Embree was not tito's fault. He pitched like s*** all year even after the Red Sox realsed him in late July. I don't think it's tito's fault when a pitcher doesn't pitch well, I mean its not like he wasnt putting him in the same situations he was sucessful in during the previous year. As for Remlinger, his success came in the much weaker national leauge after his short stint with the sox.
3. As for Renteria, there was no indiacation that the FO and tito knew exactly how hurt he was. I think that was purely Edgar's fault for not letting the Red Sox know he was hurt as bad as he probably was. As for Hanely, know one knew he was going to be as good as he was. He was a struggling minor league hitter in AA at that time. Hindsight is always 20-20.
4. Shoppach? Seriously, it's not as if the FO lost faith in him because he had two bad games. At the time he wasn't in the Sox plans to play alot. That's not Tito, that is on Theo for not giving hime more of an extended stay at the big leauge level.
5. As for Cla Merideth, if he can't handle giving up one homerun then do you really think he could have ever thrived here? Plus if you look at his stats, he is getting worse ever year in a big way. I think if he was allowed to stay in Boston after that for more than a few apperances, he would have been fine. That was another Theo not giving him more time with the club.
6. Hansen is not Tito's fault. I would blame more the Boston pitching coaching staff for tinkering him mechanics, as well as Theo for bringing him up way to soon. Explain logically how this is Franconas fault? I would love to hear this one.
7. Completely agree on Schilling, but I split the blame 75% francona, 25% Schilling for not being honest.
8. Foulke-Timlin-Papelbon
If you really remember september 2005 as well as I do, then you remember how huge it was for papelbon to come in and pitch 2-3 innings. I think the way our pitching was that year it he was more vaulable in that capacity. Timlin did a decent job as closer, but he wouldnt have had a chance to save games if paps hadn't pitched so brillantly in middle/late relief. Foulke should have been pulled by mid-may, no earlier no late IMO. The fact that he was still the closer until the end of June was a mistake. But he was an established all-star closer that deserved a chance to work himself out a little bit.
9. Bronson Arroyo does not have all-star stuff. The only reason he pitched well in the first half of 2006, was because the NL hitters hadnt seen anyone like him. Look how he has done the last two years.
10. Am I missing something, was it known Clement had an arm injury late in 2005? I thought that wasnt discovered well into 2006. Im pretty sure, I may be wrong.
11. Who else would have played secondbase? He was the secondbase men that Theo had given him, so he played him. I think it's as simple as that.
12. Finally about Manny. I have been the biggest Manny supporter here I think. But do you remember what happened that led to this? Manny refused to play on a scheduled off day, even after injuries the previous night to Damon, or Nixon I can't remember. I don't think Tito was even the one who got into it with Manny the most. I think it was Schilling, but even still Manny was WAY out of line there and deserved to have had anything happen to him that did. Also to say that Tito was the one that wanted him gone is pretty ridiculous. Theo had been tryting to get rid of this guy since 2003, and he thought he had finally gotten his justification.
There, phew that took alot out of me. Go ahead rip apart everything I said, but thats all I got.