So, I'm at work today and I have nothing to do but sit and stare at BaseballReference.com and think about baseball. Today, I was looking at Sandy Koufax for awhile and the traditional wisdom seems to be that he is the best pitcher ever. Obviously, there are a whole bunch of other names you can throw in that discussion (Randy Johnson, Bob Gibson, etc...), but I want to start a debate. I think Pedro Martinez is the best pitcher to ever tow the rubber.
To start, look at each of their best years. They both had great careers, and dominated for a decent stretch (Pedro longer, but if Koufax was around in our day, he wouldn't have had to retired early). Someone could call me out on what I consider to be each of their best years, but to determine that I'm only using the staple-stats (W-L, IP, ERA, and K). I think that paints a clear enough picture for the sake of starting this thing off.
For Pedro we're looking at 1999. Koufax, 1963.
Koufax dominated 1963 hardcore. 25 - 5, 306 K in 311 IP and and a 1.88 ERA. Dominant. It's not by accident people think he is the best. I heard somewhere that his curveball spun twice as fast as the average major league curveball. I don't know how they measured it, or anything like that, it could just be myth, but thats very impressive if true. Clearly had very good stuff. I just don't think this qualifies as one of the best years ever. Randy Johnson had a six or seven year stretch in his 30's in which I would say every year he had until his back injury was better than Koufax's best year. In a tougher league, for nine years, Johnson sustained a high level of dominance against more impressive competition facing over 1000 batters a year, I think twice. I think Koufax is very very good, but even though it wasn't the best pitching era, I would argue that the 90's into the early 2000's (?) was an era that featured the best pitchers ever. The league ERA in 1963 was 2.99, and how can you judge the dominance of one player without taking into consideration the performance of the rest of the players of that era? He dominated in a pitching dominated league. Impressive, yeah, he is crazy, but Pedro RAPED 1999.
I'll get to Pedro later, I'm getting kicked off of this computer, but come on, debate! someone yell at me for being wrong cause I must be some where.