Sorry if I'm not responding to the exact points mentioned in the above quotes, instead I'm replying to your general point of the Sox erred by not signing Clemens. First, you assumed that the Sox could have signed Roger by matching or slightly increasing the Yankee's offer.That would have been an exercise in futility. The Yankee's are desperate for pitching, and the best free agent can be obtained for cash only, end of story. So what you are saying is, the Sox should get in a straight head to head open bidding war with the Yankee's over what would be a 4 or 5 for us. For the sake of discussion, let's say we got him ( which never would have happened, since the Yankee's would have paid whatever it takes ), he'd be a # 4 or # 5 on the the Sox's current staff. So you're telling me that a 40+ year old, that pitched in the NL, averaging 5-6 innings per start, a projected ERA in the AL east of 3.50 - 4.0 +, should be the highest paid pitcher on the Sox staff ? I'm sorry he's not worth it. Maybe to the Yanks, but certainly not to the Sox. Personally, I think he's a pitcher that's past his usefulness, over priced, and he's never proved to be clutch in the play-offs.
I'm glad the Yank's got him, he'll only wear down the bull pen and let them down in the play-offs ( if they make it ).