This kind of shows that you still don't get it. Think of the top 20 players in MLB (there are 6x more players in MiLB - so I've reduced the consideration accordingly). If Dustin Pedroia is the 10th best player in all of MLB one year, and is then 11th the next year.....would you say he's going in the wrong direction? In terms of rankings, it would be appropriate to do so, which is why I think you are doing it, but I'd be surprised if you thought so. Little variances in performance from year to year happen all the time and these blips impact ranking lists, but that doesn't mean Pedroia isn't a fantastic, talented player that you'd want on your team.