Buchholz + Anyone not named Bard, and I think they should have done the deal. If Bard was a sticking point for Toronto, then it was smart to pass. Papelbon has been a ticking BSL all season. Bard is looking like good insurance should they need someone else to finish out games down the stretch and in October.
Speaking of insurance, this is why Kotchman makes sense. Like Kilo has mentioned, he's an ideal bench player. Not only does he play good D at his position, he also stikes out seldomly. He'll make a great PH. Which is nice, but what he really does is provide insurance for the ticking clock that is Lowell's hip. If you, and you know who I'm talking to, are going to get up on the soapbox and moan about an OF should Drew go down, at least be honest and apply that same concern to Lowell. Failure to acknowledge this benefit makes it look like bitching for the sake of bitching. Yes, Martinez can play 1B full-time if Lowell goes down, but then we don't have a backup C.
Not only is it a similar concern, but it is one that can't be addressed through our minor league system. Our best and closest to ready minor league prospect can play all three OF positions. We don't really have anyone showing signs of readiness at the CIF. It's hilarious, but totally unsurprising, that it's being suggested that Reddick can't replace Kotsay right now. Kotsay f***ing sucks. Full stop. I can understand favoring some experience over giving a prospect a shot, but this is beyond reason. It's pathological.