What a stupid question? How could the best, and most complete player in baseball today, and perhaps ever, be overrated? Sure, his asking price is way too high, but that doesnt take away from his skill. If someone wants to pay near 200 million to get him, they gotta take the monetary hit, while still getting the best player in the game though. He hits for power, average, gets on base, steals, and fields, five things that I actually dont think anyone else can do. Ichiro is close, but he cant hit for power. There is no way in hell that Carlos Beltran is overrated