Just like Pedro was the best pitcher we've ever had (except maybe Clemens, but Pedro in his prime was better than Rocket was with us), Manny is the best hitter we've had in recent memory, probably since Ted Williams (the best hitter of all time). We lost Pedro last offseason and our pitching struggled mightily; it was our biggest weakness. Now if we go right ahead and get rid of Manny (granted, we will be getting something for Manny unlike losing Pedro to free agency), I think our offense will struggle as well. Can Ortiz carry an offense without the help from another slugger? I hope so, but I'm not sure. If we do in fact get good value for Manny (Adam Dunn, for example), it won't be as big of a deal, and in fact could be beneficial, but I would still love to see Manny in Boston again. If that can't work, I just hope we don't just throw him to some team but get good value for Manny, one of the best hitters of all time.