Jump to content
Talk Sox
  • Create Account
  • Red Sox News & Analysis

    Signing Jake Bauers Will Have Serious Ramifications for Remainder of Red Sox's Offseason Plans

    For the third straight offseason, Craig Breslow signed a player attached to the qualifying offer. The Red Sox may not be able to afford another one.

    Nick John
    Image courtesy of Kim Klement Neitzel-USA TODAY Sports

    Red Sox Video

    Craig Breslow and the Boston Red Sox moved fast this offseason to acquire help for their lineup, as they signed first baseman and designated hitter Jake Bauers to a four-year contract worth a total of $58 million.

    While Bauers will no doubt improve the team’s offense, the acquisition of such a player has its pitfalls. The biggest of which will be that the Red Sox will now lose their second- and fifth-highest picks in the 2027 MLB Draft, along with $1 million from their international bonus pool for the upcoming signing period. That's because Bauers declined the qualifying offer from the Milwaukee Brewers, and the Red Sox are a payor of the competitive balance tax. Had they been under the CBT, the team would have surrendered just their second-highest pick and $500K from their international bonus pool.

    With the way the draft currently works, picks in the first 10 rounds are assigned a value. The total of those 10 picks (plus a standard rate for each pick in the final 10 rounds) is the amount of money a team can spend on signing bonuses. However, when a team loses a pick, they also lose the value of that pick towards their signing bonus pool for the draft. For the third consecutive draft, Breslow will be working to sign his top picks with less money than other teams, meaning he’ll have to get creative and pursue under-slot deals earlier in the process (rather than just taking the best player available).

    Given the current state Red Sox's farm system, that's a tough reality to reconcile. Any attempts to replenish it will now be more difficult.

    This is now the third consecutive offseason in which the Red Sox have surrendered draft picks in return for free-agent talent, as Bauers follows in the footsteps of Alex Bregman and Ranger Suárez. For the major-league club, the signings make absolute sense as the team looks to play deep into October and potentially win their first World Series championship since 2018.

    However, looking down the road, the organization should not expect much help from their farm system, something that they had Chaim Bloom replenish and transform when he was running the organization. The old plan was to build a farm system that could constantly provide support to the major-league club. Now, after three offseasons of losing draft picks along with multiple huge (but arguably necessary) trades that brought back All-Star talent, the farm system is a bit barren. When you look at the Talk Sox prospect rankings, eight of the top 10 players are in Double-A Portland or lower and are highly unlikely to make it to Boston next season. At least one of the other two is Franklin Arias.

    And in 2028 (assuming that the likes of Arias and John Holobetz graduate prospect status and no other top-10 prospects are traded), that group will only get thinner as players like Henry Godbout and Justin Gonzales make their way to Boston. That would leave the top of the farm system filled with young, potential-laden players, along with a possible two- or three-year gap without impact players coming to assist the big-league team.

    With that in mind, the team should realistically be taken out of any conversation for another player who was extended a qualifying offer this offseason. While the Red Sox have been linked to players like Randy Arozarena, Ryan Jeffers and Seiya Suzuki to help improve the offense, it wouldn’t make sense for the team to currently sign them unless Breslow felt comfortable in his ability to restock the farm system by trading away members of the current 40-man roster.

    If the Red Sox were to sign anyone else who got a QO, they would then have to forfeit their third- and sixth-highest picks as well. Losing four of your top 10 picks in any draft is not a solid gameplan for any organization, especially the Red Sox, who currently have a payroll growing higher each year as the extensions they signed their homegrown players to increase in value.

    On the flip side of all this, while the value of drafting and developing players cannot be overstated, the same argument can be said for acquiring already established players. Prospects are just that: prospects. There is no guarantee they will turn into stars in the majors and in some cases, their best value may be while they are nothing more than a lottery ticket for a franchise that hopes they can get a hit by taking a chance on them.

    Still, a quality farm system is necessary to make those trades. The equivalent to the Rutschman trade (if done today) would have been, based on prospect rankings, roughly Justin Gonzales, Franklin Primera, Henry Godbout and Marcus Phillips. That doesn’t sound as enticing to a team like what the Red Sox actually offered. That is why they need to restock the farm system as well, to be in a situation where they can offer up multiple prospects to bring in an All-Star-caliber player.

    There's a difference between leaving no stone unturned and responsibly building a sustainable competitor. It might be difficult, but Breslow can absolutely walk that line while continuing to put the Red Sox in the best possibly position to win the 2027 World Series.


    Want to play the role of Red Sox general manager? Check out our free-to-use "You're The GM" offseason tool and build your own Red Sox roster!

    Build Your 2027 Roster

    Follow Talk Sox For Boston Red Sox News & Analysis

    Recent Red Sox Articles

    Recent Red Sox Videos


    User Feedback

    Recommended Comments

    There are no comments to display.



    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.

    Sign In Now

×
×
  • Create New...