Jump to content
Talk Sox
  • Create Account

S5Dewey

Verified Member
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    7,043

  • Joined

  • Last visited

 Content Type 

Profiles

Boston Red Sox Videos

2026 Boston Red Sox Top Prospects Ranking

Boston Red Sox Free Agent & Trade Rumors, Notes, & Tidbits

Guides & Resources

2025 Boston Red Sox Draft Pick Tracker

News

Forums

Blogs

Events

Store

Downloads

Gallery

Everything posted by S5Dewey

  1. S5Dewey
    Fine. But if you're going to post part of a conversation that happened yesterday at least post it accurately. To suggest that it was said that it was smart to strike out in that situation is disingenuous at best and dishonest at worst.
  2. S5Dewey
    Now let's talk about what you posted in this thread: Let's hear again from the advocates who believe that, with men on 1b and 3b with 1 out, the smart play by Manny was to strike out. The rally would still be alive if he had played it smart. And, yes, that was said on a game thread the other night. There were no "advocates"who believe that striking out in that situation is the "Smart" thing to do. What was implied was that striking out would be better than hitting into a double play. And I'd stand by that.
  3. S5Dewey
    Oh for Chrissake! NOBODY said it was the smart thing to do. What was said was that a K is better than the DP.
  4. S5Dewey
    Limiting to defense I think it's hard to say. IMO Mookie covers more ground out there than Dewey did but Evans has/had a better arm. On a day-to-day basis (and leaving offense out of the equation) I think I'd take Mookie. A fielder had more chances to run down a ball than to showcase his arm. But either of them is fine with me.
  5. S5Dewey
    Beni?
  6. S5Dewey
    Another one by Mookie!
  7. S5Dewey
    So he's #4/5 in the Fielding Bible - usually accepted as the Gold Standard for fielding - and middle of the pack statistically. When people who rate defense for a living can't agree on how good JBJ is how can mere underlings like us have any faith in defensive ratings?
  8. S5Dewey
    That's a totally unfair comparison. A lot of that has to do with who Blair was competing against for the award vs who JBJ is competing against.
  9. S5Dewey
    That HR aside, this is still a much better outing than I'd feared from Mr. Tingles.
  10. S5Dewey
    Crap. One out away from the shutout. Ugh
  11. S5Dewey
    Yep. I agree. I just thought we were listing all the things Mookie is better than anyone else at.
  12. S5Dewey
  13. S5Dewey
    When it came time for JDM to hit he was "on the can" so they sent Swi up to PH for him. Ok.. I made that part up.
  14. S5Dewey
    Stomach problems. Possibly something he ate?
  15. S5Dewey
    I hope you and Alex aren't arguing with the statistics.
  16. S5Dewey
    Ya, but if a kid was drowning, JBJ walked on the water to save the kid you'd say that JBJ can't swim. I know.. it's an old joke, but appropriate.
  17. S5Dewey
    Well, you've got it!!
  18. S5Dewey
    It was. It looked like something Bradley would do.
  19. S5Dewey
    Yeah! Ain't it great?? That f***er has taken so many backhanded swipes at the Red Sox that I don't care if he gets raped by a group of homeless people and left for dead. f*** him. Figuratively speaking, of course.
  20. S5Dewey
    That was classic. Showalter got to the mound before XBo got to the plate!
  21. S5Dewey
    I don't know, but any day Buck Showalter loses a game is a good day!
  22. S5Dewey
    Not only do the Sox have 5 SB's there hasn't been a throw to 2B! Amazing
  23. S5Dewey
    Is it me, or are the wheels starting to come off for Baltimore now?
  24. S5Dewey
    I'm a big JBJ fan, but... how do you walk a guy who's hitting 9th and batting .170??
  25. S5Dewey
    Beni has a good enough arm, and when opposing runners try to run on balls hit off that wall they're sitting ducks. That ball was there and waiting for Valencia!
×
×
  • Create New...