The idea that Costas is a stupid person's idea of what a smart person sounds like is absolutely dead on, you could not be any more on target, it's genius, I love it! I always liked John Miller, and didn't have the problem with Joe Morgan that a lot of people have. McCarver has vast knowledge, but he's also part Costas in that he wants to make sure you know he knows it and has been everywhere and seen everything. He's also seemed slanted against the Sox at times, and so does Joe Buck, especially when it involved the Cardinals. I agree about Vin Scully, but I'd add a name that none of you have. I grew up listening to Marty Brenaman in Cincy--one of the all time best announcers ever. He's not in the HOF for no reason. When I first started listening to Sox games, I was shocked at how easy they were on the team. I didn't realize not everyone is as hard line as he is when the team screws something up. Thom I don't care for as much, I tolerate him, but I love Marty.