How would you fairly assess his 4 years here?
Personally, I never understood all the hate he received. Did he under-perform for his price? Sure. But with the guys around him he was never supposed to be THE guy, especially when it came to driving in runs. He got on base for the guys around him and played an excellent right field. That's one area in which I'll miss Drew... I have worries about Sweeney/Ross stepping into right. It can be an adventure out there with the wrong guy. We've been fortunate to have had Nixon and Drew out there for years. Last year was scary with Reddick, who I thought was just awful defensively.
I know people had gripes about his personality, how he was too quiet and such. Didn't really bother me. What did bother me was how he always seemed to get on base when all hope was lost, yet when they needed him on, he failed to. Certainly not in the postseason, but regular season definitely.
I don't think we'll necessary miss Drew (and definitely not his contract), but part of me thinks his OBP and OPS, 2011 aside, went under-valued.