At some point in the middle of this utter and complete two year disaster, the Sox are going to have to deal with having ignored run prevention to the extent that they have. We don't have sound defense. We have defensive standouts in particular positions but not in the most important positions. Give me a plus defender at SS and Catcher and give me minus defenders at 1st base and elsewhere all day long. Don't give me minus defenders at SS and Catcher and then tell me the defense is sound cause I have plus defenders at 1st and 2nd base and don't talk to me about adequate defenders at SS and Catcher because in doing so you have de-facto doomed the defense to minus status in the overall.
The outfield is basically armless. Crawford has so far been a disaster in LF and I continue to point out that he has sucked coming in on balls never mind what he has or has not done at the wall. Ells is far and away the best of them as far as ranging in the outfield, catching up to and catching the ball but that is as far as it goes. Aviles is a butcher at SS. Salty continues to be a terrible catcher having improved his throwing only over these last two years while continuing to do what appears to be a terrible job handling the pitching staff. So far WMB has not been an upgrade to Youk defensively although I continue to hope that will improve.
I said in another thread that if I had chosen to track it I am convinced that I could have found an error or a defensive play not made or a double play that should have been made resulting in extra outs for the opposition in virtually every game this year. While the starting pitching is by far the biggest problem this team has, it only overshadows the lack of timely hitting and poor defense by this club by virtue of how bad the starting pitching has been. However you add Salty's numbers as a factor in how bad the pitching has been and you begin to see how much this organization has ignored run prevention in total as a consequence of focusing almost its entire attention on glamour signings that have simply added more disassociated pieces to this team, adding to its disfunction and lack of cohesiveness in virtually every aspect of the game. Fortunately it has not destroyed the farm system in the process having only put something of a hole in the train of players that should be making their way to the bigs.
But by the time this season is done, IMO, we will not have a one year disaster but two years of utter and complete failure at the ML level. The starting pitching deserves the most attention going forward because starting pitching is so important but there is much about this team that is not just wrong but critically wrong. I have railed against this notion that you accept a butcher at SS because he can hit constantly at this forum and while it might be hard for some to see how and why Aviles is a butcher at SS, you don't have to be that astute an observer to see that he is not a plus defender at SS and his hitting is simply nothing to write home about. As for Salty, most of his HR's have been meaningless bombs lost in the background noise of yet another loss while his defense and lack of effectiveness handling the pitchers is something the team has to live with, every pitch of every game he catches.