I should also point out that JBJ's .235BA is not far from what we always said would be fine by us, a .250 and maybe a .750-.775 OPS.
Crash was right and he is right. The dif between .235 and .250 is a dying quail, an infield hit, a seeing eye per week at most. But JBJ cannot go up there and just swing at air AB after AB or he will not get hat dying quail or infield hit per week.
He is what he is. His swing has too many moving parts and he simply cannot either control them nor does he even make much of an effort to recognize what is happening to them enough to change his career slash profile.
JBJ thinks his swing is not changing and he refuses to modify it when in fact its changing all the time. He let that torso mess of his get so out of hand in 2014 that he was literally turning himself into a corkscrew in the batters box.
While dropping his front shoulder is getting it out of the way of his head thus preventing him from tilting his head to the point where he can't even see the ball into the strike zone, he will go too far with that eventually...bet the mortgage on it and he will be turning his whole upper body into the strike zone before too long. Christ Catchers will be complaining that he is blocking their effort to catch the ball.
Sorry to sound sarcastic. But I have simply watched too many JBJ AB's and he is now too much of an old dog. He's not going to change. He would have to completely rebuild his swing to a much quieter swing and then we would have to graft JD's head onto JBJ's body so that JBJ thought about hitting the way JD thinks about hitting.
JD does not care what his swing feels like. He cares what his swing looks like. If it looks right, the feel will come. If as a hitter, you depend on feel, you might feel great and have the worst swing anybody ever saw. If we can't tell that is what JBJ has been doing for 6 years at least, we have just not been watching.