This mistake with Sale was extending him. Who on Gods green earth thinks we want a Pitcher who has shown signs of wearing down over the course of the season all the way out to 2024 at $29M per? I am not questioning whether he could or did pass a physical before signing. I am confident he did. What does that have to do with anything? What the f*** was that. That is an albatross around our necks. That is what that is.
Mookie is simply too diminutive a player to take the risk inherent to making him a $30M per player playing Manfred-ball. He is literally one wrist injury from being turned into the most average player we are ever going to see and he is only 5-9, 180. Let somebody else do it and be happy with the result. We got a championship out of his run here. I would ONLY keep him around and let him go as a FA if I had a genuine, feeling we had the pieces around him to make a very serious run to another ring...not a run to the division or the WC but a serous run at ALCS at least. Frankly, I think there is too much fixing that needs doing here for that sort of confidence. Yes, he does have to adapt to pitchers not giving him his favorite pitch as often. He probably will which is no guarantee that he will handle what they ARE throwing him. That said the general quality of pitching in MLB is so piss poor that he can reliably expect to get pitches to hit. There are far too many pitchers pitching in MLB that are wild in the strike zone. In fact I think noise about expansion is laughable. Where are players going to come from for two more MLB teams? Most specifically where are the pitchers going to come from or will Manfred just proclaim again that "these are the greatest hitters in history" [hitting rocket ship baseballs thrown by pitchers that belong in A ball]?
Why are Bogie, Devers and Vaz doing as well as they are doing? Because they are hitting virtually everything thrown up to the plate at them...low and away, low and in, up and out over, breaking balls, FB's WHATEVER.....they are hitting it. I am reluctant to put JBJ in that category because we never know when JBJ is going to wake up one morning and turn into ......THE OTHER JBJ. The two SUPERSTARS are doing none of that. Chavis is just benefiting from so many pitchers throwing crap breaking balls right down main st which it appears he just can't miss and the occasional FB below his belt.
The rotation sucks balls. But I am not willing to simply ignore the fact that they ALL REALLY sucked balls for 4 turns through at the start of the regular season. What if for example the lack of ST stints was simply the visible manifestation of a light work load throughout ST? Erod had the best starts through that period followed by Price. There is simply no ignoring how bad they were through 4 turns right at the start. None of them could throw a Change to save their lives. They were all up and out over with Change ups which is death for that pitch, every one of them exhibited that tendency.
I am in agreement with the bolded text in the quote. Though this tendency to fall in love with players by management, not the fans is as much responsible as anything. Never mind whether we fall in love with them or not. We don't have a seat at the Baseball Ops table. Why for example did DD feel the need to validate his choices to supplement the 2018 championship run by signing Pearce at all and signing Eovaldi for too much money? DD had done his job and those two players had done theirs. What the f*** did any of that have to do with 2019?