I have been a baseball fan since 1962. By 1964 and at the age of eleven years-old, I had a pretty serious grasp on the game of baseball and especially the Boston Red Sox. My family and I went to lots of games in the early 60s when you could just walk up to Fenway and get box seats for about $5.00 each.
As a kid, I played baseball and whiffle ball almost every day. I was also a voracious reader on the subject. I read The Sporting News cover-to-cover each week. It was 99% baseball stories and statics in the 1960-70s and was known as the Baseball Bible. I had hundreds of baseball cards and studied them. I had hundreds of statistics (Hr, RBI, Avg, W-L, BB, SO, ERA) memorized.
I have always loved baseball. I still watch virtually every Red Sox game as well a others I can get on my MLB television package. For me, it isn't about embracing the statistical side and dismissing the visual side. They both totally enhance each other. It is like a scientific study. I make observations, draw conclusions, and look at the statistics to support my opinions. Baseball isn't just a passion, it is a lifelong study.
To me, statistics are necessary on a baseball board. It comes down to using hard evidence (statistical facts) supporting a reasoned judgment versus someone expressing an opinion based on just more opinion.