I don't know who is judging him by the boxscore. We're judging him based on 8 years of horrid bullpen use. He's completely lost in terms of bullpen management unless he can go Bard - Pap.
It's not like he used to be good and then stopped. Last year, through the middle of the season, he started having a quick trigger with the bullpen and we started winning a lot of games. This year? He waits for implosions before warming anyone up.
The thing is, if he's so worried about our bullpen arms that he's willing to let Lackey turn a 1 run game into a 6 run game in a matter of 3 hitters, then maybe we should look into restructuring our bullpen.
First thing - get rid of Wakefield. He's not an effective reliever, and when Jenks and Wheeler get back, Wake should be one of the ones to go. He's entirely too one-dimensional and we have Aceves who can spot start and be much more effective and *key word* consistent than Wakefield.
Second thing - We need to just man up and go with a 13 man staff. Darnell McDonald has had 20 AB in 37 games this year. He is providing us nothing in depth, and when he does get up to the plate, he's hitting .150. Regardless, our problem right now is NOT hitting. We're hitting much better than we have been all year. Our problem is pitching. We need to DFA D-Mac (or look to trade him) and bring up someone from AAA (Doubront would be great). Then, when Wheeler and Jenks get back, we need to DFA Wakefield and option Okajima.
It's like Francona doesn't evaluate the team needs, he just goes with what's out there. He doesn't look to improve the team at all. He doesn't realize that having a one-dimensional, inconsistent knuckle baller in the bullpen is a wasted roster spot.
A bench of Varitek - Scutaro - Cameron, and a bullpen of Papelbon - Bard - Jenks - Albers - Wheeler - Aceves - Hill - Doubront would be much, much more effective and would cater to Francona's horrid bullpen management. If he would learn to go to the pen before shooting ourselves in the foot every game, we would be above .500.