So you would rather eat more money and get less in return to send him to an NL team??
Come on man. Have some faith in your own ball club. The Sox have WMB at 3B, are getting last years AL MVP of position players in Ellsbury AND Carl Crawford back at the ASB, Beckett back in a matter of days. They have Franklin Morales who has really come in and been a stud, and if he sticks, he's a well above average 5th man in the rotation.
Gonzo is starting to get it going. Pedroia is clearly getting hot. We get Cody Ross back who knocks the piss out of LHP.
Like I said - Have some faith in your own guys. If they can't make the PS because of 1 game, it's not going to be because of Youkilis. It's going to be because they couldn't hold a lead in the 9th or the 11th against the Tigers, or because they couldn't hold a 9 run lead against the Yankees, or it'll be because they gave up a 9th inning, go ahead HR to Sean Rodriguiz.