How about Salty? How would that have looked? Because the only way we go after Martin, is if we didn't trade for Salty in the prior deadline. I say that as someone who, at the time, was perhaps the most prominent supporter of going to get Martin as he would have been a good low-risk investment.
We'd have had people coming in here making the same point you just made, only in reverse. Salty is, after all, outhitting Martin on the year, and he is younger, with fewer injury problems in his past.
We made the right call on that one -- and given that Salty still has upside and Martin pretty much is what he is, I think we're on the right side of that particular line.
I like Lavarnway as a prospect, but counting on him to develop into a big league fulltime starting catcher is still a leap of faith, so I'm very glad we have Salty around to hold down the fort.