Oh I know two won't win it. That was a dumb/bold.. dumb prediction. But I do consider Hamilton a contestant for it. And Ellsbury is still a rookie, you can't really say either way.
And no one's done it since '67, true, but look...
[table=comparison]Player|Date|BA|HR|RBI
Yastrzemski|May 1967|.301|8|22
Hamilton|May 2008|.322|8|29[/table]
Doesn't that count for anything?