Well, I for one am taken aback by that analysis. It was astute while being thought provoking. I'm sorry but I really am enjoying this time in our history. Whining Yankee fans are my favorite.
Pardon the interruption and am no "stat man" by any stretch of the imagination. But, Melky has had 4 years of major league experience and while still young doesn't impress me as a superstar in the making based on his career numbers that I just looked at to pass the time. Also, let's look at the only season that really matters.
Small sample size because well the MFY's don't stay in very long these days, but there is a trend
6 games. 19 ABs. 2 R. 3 H. .158 BA. .158 OBP .316 Slg
Jacoby
11 games. 25 ABs. 8 R. 9 H. .360 BA. .429 OBP .520 Slg.
For those of you (me) that just watch the games as well and believe in intangibles beyond stats. Some got it...some not so much. And the proof as they say is in the pudding and I still don't know what in the hell that saying means.
I also didn't jump to conclusions about Shane Spencer. Anyone...anyone.