In regards to trading DiceK, he would have a nice market, and we could probably get something decent in return. I mean his salary is what only 6 million per year? Alot of NL teams would love to have him.
To say that JD completely rakes is ridiculous. Minus one month in June last year, he has not raked with this team. I know he is a valuable player, but come on. I know he is a clutch player as well, and glad he is on the team.
He would still be worth it.
edit- plus he has only made two errors this year in 140 total chances. He is young, young infielders go through growing pains in the field alot of times. He could turn out to be a decent fielder.