Yeah, I personally don't think A-rod really embodies the idea of the MVP. Sure throw numbers at me all day, but at the end of a day, to me at least, it really comes down to how tough a competitor he is, and how dependent his team is on him. A-rod isn't even the MVP of his team, Derek Jeter is, or Mariano Rivera. Without A-rod that team is still a force, with out Derek or Mariano, the team would not have finished in first place and would not have been so much of a force. Thats my two sense, tear it apart if you want, cause I'm sure its flawed but thats how I think. I'm old school when it comes to this stuff. Its all about winning with MVP, how much your team needs you, how much better you make the guys around you and how much you contribute to the teams success. I just think that A-rod isn't a good MVP.
I recognize he had awesome stats, and he is the fantasy MVP, I would take Ortiz on my team over A-rod anyday of the week and I'd even stick him at first base. Oh well, life goes on. To be honest though, if I had a vote it would go to Mariano Rivera, if you're going to tear me apart for this at least don't call me a homer.
Re-posting this cause it got lost in the shuffle of a merge. And because i like my opinion better than anyone elses, because its mine and different and special in its own way. Something along those lines.