When Manny Schilling Trot Lowell and Foulke are gone we have Pedroia, Lester, Papelbon, Hansen, Delcarmen and Wily Mo to look forward too. Just because guys will get old and move on doesn't justify moving a prospect. As a matter of fact, thats the reason for keeping a prospect. Not sure what your logic is there. Why are you desparate to win right now? Why do you think what we have in our system won't carry us down the road? It doesn't make sense to me that you always want to sell the farm for right now this second. Honestly, this is always your opinion and it drives me nuts because I can't figure it out. A rotation of Lester, Papelbon, Beckett and Bowden will be scary a couple years from now. Yes, I am including Bowden. I'm not one of those crazy fans who buys into every prospect but I am in love with Michael Bowden. He has crazy stuff and nice mound presence. This team has a lot of potential down the road. Granted, Dontrelle is a young guy, I just don't see him as an ace. I would rather sign a Clemens and keep my prospects.
You're skewing the facts right now to try to make your point. Right now, Lester is on pace to crack the rotation next year. Willis is a good pitcher, and I understand he is 24, but I question his durability. I'd like to see this guy get another ace-like season in under his belt before I sell the farm for him. He has had terrible second halves two years in a row before last year. Unfortunetly we don't have time to wait around. I would vote no on this based on what I have seen of Dontrelle in the past. You on the other hand are itching to deal away young talent all the time, so I see why you would like this. To me Lester and Pedroia would be way too much.
Think about it in terms you can grasp, if you had Pettitte and Eckstien, would you trade them along with a Manny Delcarmen for Dontrelle? When you put it like that, you're getting raped. Lester and Pedroia have that kind of potential. I'm not in any rush to send them anywhere for anybody.
I'd like to have Willis in my rotation and you're right, he helps now and later but I think Lester has the potential to help more later than Dontrelle will. Don't get me wrong, I wouldn't be crying if this happened because he is a good pitcher, but I think we would need something else before we part with these prospects. If Hansen is involved I would absolutely hang up the phone. Lester is gettable considering that Dontrelle is coming back the other way, but I'm very leery about trading Pedroia.