He's better then what the other two that we have on the rotation; Dice-k and Buchholtz. I never said he was better then mediocre. Just that he's been one of our best pitchers this year.
No, I’m saying your expectations are too high for a 5th slot rookie starter. He’s had great games and that just goes out the window for you because he is laying an egg. What pitcher on this staff hasn’t done that this year? I’d go as far as say he’s been our second or third best pitcher this year.
What's the ERA for everyone else on this staff? I'd say he's been a good 5th guy, that's also a rookie. Your judging him like he is the ace of the staff.
I don't know why they are so in love with the guy. He does have some flashes of being able to be an average player. But, for the most part, he doesn't do anything. To top it all off he drops more balls then an outfielder on the Bad News Bears.